Life cycle assessment (LCA), in simplified definition, is a task that uncovers all environmental effects a process or a product creates. It is a difficult task and one that is complex. Why is it so complex? Mainly, because the environment can be harmed in multiple ways and because emissions can have multiple levels of impact.
The six goals of LCA
A usual life cycle analysis focuses on six different goals or six ways in which the environment needs to be protected. To mention the most important ones: there is the greenhouse effect, the ozone hole, eutrophication, noise emission, human toxicity and eco toxicity. Including all six of these concerns in a single analysis takes a lot of expertise and requires sophisticated LCA tools.
What is a Carbon Footprint? A reduced Life Cycle Assessment
The complexity of LCA, however, can be drastically reduced by limiting the analysis to one single environmental effect. That is exactly what carbon footprints allow: a reduced LCA that exclusively assesses one type of emission, or one type of in- and output.
By reducing the complexity of LCAs to one level of impact, you take life cycle thinking one step toward practical relevance. This is the reason why full LCAs seem to remain prominent in the academic sector, whereas carbon footprints have clearly entered into wide-spread use in business.
Life Cycle Thinking for Practitioners: Single Score Footprinting
Results for carbon footprints, be it for organizations, processes or products, comprise one figure. One figure, one single score, can be compared to others. As long as you follow a uniform methodology, e.g. ISO 14067 for carbon footprinting, this single score is very significant. Product carbon footprints which show the carbon footprint figure for one functional entity, hence one product, have a huge potential for customers to compare products and choose the least polluting.
Comparable results are satisfying, but not the only advantage of “single score footprinting”. Prof. Dr. Mario Schmidt, expert for industrial ecology, argues that conventional cost accounting methods can easily be transferred to footprinting analysis. How that works? We have summarized it in the following.
Carbon Footprint: Accumulates All Greenhouse Gas Emissions
In a complex production system, the production process consists of many sub-processes. Every sub-process “inherits” carbon emissions from its predecessor, and generates further direct emissions on top. The final product, which results from all the steps of the production process, possesses their accumulated GHG emissions.
Greenhouse gas emissions, when visualized, usually follow an arrow pointing up into the air, since this is how carbon dioxide is imagined to enter the atmosphere. The following sankey diagram, however, shows us a view of emissions going the other way: carbon-equivalent emissions point downwards, into the process. The logic behind this visualization is clear: emissions are cumulative. Remember? Accumulated GHG emissions.
Process structure and emission calculation including the upstream chain. Material flow model with CO2-equivalents created with the software Umberto.
But how can you assign a certain level of emissions to the following production stream where there are two or more interrelated processes and/or benefits? This question arises from what business economists call joint products, and correct allocation is needed. To give you an example:
A sub-process generates a product (good) and waste (bad). What happens if you can sell the waste as a raw material instead? In this case, the same sub-process generates a product (good) and another product (also good). In the following illustration, this is shown as process B. Processes B and C don’t necessarily need to happen in the same company. The difficulty is determining how much of the process emissions need to be assigned to one and how much to the other product.
Allocation problem because of various benefits and recycling of material. Material flow model created with the software Umberto.
Emission x Factor = Material x Unit Cost
There are two ways in which traditional accounting would solve this problem. Why traditional accounting? Because the ecological footprinting perspective is very similar to the financial accounting one. Really? Yes, just change the units: in footprinting, you have
[weight of GHG emission] x [emission factor]
whereas with cost accounting you have
[amount of material] x [unit costs]
OK, but what is it good for? The accounting methods are well developed and tested and allocation of overhead expense, for example, is extremely useful regarding product carbon footprints, and easily feasible, too.
Allocation: by Amount or by Market Price?
Back to resolving the allocation problem. One of the two methods looks at product amount, in weight or in pieces. You can find this approach in ISO 14040 on environmental management. The other approach allocates costs (in accounting) or emissions (in footprinting) by market prices. The latter can be found in PAS 2050, the British standard on carbon footprinting. So, if a process results in 9 kg of product A, worth $3 and 1 kg of product B, worth $7 our first approach would allocate 90% of the emissions to product A, whereas only 30% of the emissions would be allocated to it using the market price approach. Got it?
I hope to have given you some insight into the possibilities of cost accounting in carbon footprinting.
Original article written by Moritz Bühner.
Article image by Keith Williamson.
References:
Schmidt, M.,2011. Von der Material- und Energieflussanalyse zum Carbon Footprint – Anleihen aus der Kostenrechnung .Chemie Ingenieur Technik
- Products & Solutions (100)
- Trends & Technology (99)
- News & Updates (68)
- Challenges (67)
- Sustainability (49)
- life cycle assessment (44)
- Energy efficiency (30)
- Compliance (28)
- circular economy (23)
- carbon footprint (22)
- echa (21)
- LCA (19)
- Resource efficiency (19)
- SCIP (19)
- Umberto (18)
- Material flow cost accounting (15)
- material flow analysis (13)
- Renewable energy (11)
- material efficiency (11)
- Process Optimization (10)
- environmental product declaration (9)
- Ecodesign (8)
- Efficiency (8)
- Trends (8)
- Customer driven-sustainability (7)
- Eco label (7)
- Ipoint suite (7)
- Lca databases (7)
- Supply chain (7)
- Survey (7)
- Sustainable development (7)
- blockchain (7)
- Renewable heat (6)
- automotive (6)
- research (6)
- China (5)
- Corporate carbon footprint (5)
- Digitalization (5)
- Materialflusskostenrechnung (5)
- carbon footprinting (5)
- digital product passport (5)
- waste management (5)
- Chemical industry (4)
- Climate protection (4)
- Cobalt reporting (4)
- OECD (4)
- Okobilanzierung (4)
- Sustainable transport (4)
- carbon neutrality (4)
- construction industry (4)
- germany (4)
- Big Data (3)
- Brexit (3)
- Conflict minerals (3)
- Corporate Social Responsibility (3)
- Database (3)
- Due diligence (3)
- Environmental product declarations (3)
- Eutrophication (3)
- IFEU (3)
- ISO 50001 (3)
- Leed (3)
- Medical device (3)
- Photovoltaics (3)
- Ressourceneffizienz (3)
- Social media (3)
- building sector (3)
- carbon neutral (3)
- greenhouse gas inventory (3)
- transport sector (3)
- water footprint (3)
- 20-20-20 Objectives (2)
- 3D printing (2)
- BASF (2)
- Christian-Doppler-Laboratory (2)
- Conflict minerals reporting (2)
- Cycling (2)
- E-car (2)
- Environmental impact (2)
- Environmental management (2)
- Environmental performance (2)
- Fish (2)
- Gate to gate (2)
- Global warming (2)
- Governance (2)
- Green business 2 (2)
- Green investment (2)
- Human rights (2)
- Inatba (2)
- Integrated reporting (2)
- Integrative approach (2)
- Knowledge economy (2)
- MFA (2)
- Okobilanz (2)
- Renewable Resources (2)
- Sdgs (2)
- Software (2)
- Steady state economy (2)
- Sustainable business (2)
- Sustainable lifestyle (2)
- UK REACH (2)
- Umberto for carbon footprint (2)
- Umweltbundesamt (2)
- agriculture (2)
- best practice (2)
- biodiversity (2)
- biomass (2)
- building standards (2)
- carbon intensity (2)
- carbon relocation (2)
- collaborative consumption (2)
- consistency (2)
- corporate material flow modeling (2)
- cost savings (2)
- developing world (2)
- eLCAr (2)
- energiewende (2)
- energy (2)
- esankey (2)
- food industry (2)
- green jobs (2)
- holistic approach (2)
- milk (2)
- modern slavery (2)
- okobilanzdaten (2)
- productivity (2)
- resilience (2)
- sankey diagram (2)
- seafood (2)
- transport (2)
- 2012 (1)
- 3 scopes (1)
- ACHEMA (1)
- AI (1)
- Abfallwirtschaft (1)
- Ankara (1)
- B2B (1)
- BMBF (1)
- BREEAM (1)
- Bachelor program (1)
- Bauwesen (1)
- Brazil (1)
- CFC (1)
- CO2-Fußabdruck (1)
- Central america (1)
- Circular Economy Action Plan (1)
- Comparative life cycle assessment (1)
- Composite indicator (1)
- Construction (1)
- Consumer goods (1)
- Consumption (1)
- Country Attractiveness (1)
- Creative sustainability (1)
- Csr report (1)
- Data (1)
- Data collection (1)
- Davos (1)
- Decarbonization (1)
- Denmark (1)
- Design (1)
- Deutschland (1)
- Developing countries (1)
- Dienstleistungen (1)
- Distributed manufacturing (1)
- Domestic sector (1)
- Earth Sciences (1)
- Earth summit (1)
- Ecolabelling (1)
- Ecological resilience (1)
- Efficiency measures (1)
- Effizienzfabrik (1)
- Ehs (1)
- Emission relocation (1)
- Ems (1)
- Energieeffizienz (1)
- Energy Intensity by Sector (1)
- Engineering excellence (1)
- Environmental Contracting (1)
- Environmental Engineering (1)
- Environmental capital (1)
- Environmentally Weighed Material Consumption (1)
- European Comission (1)
- European Green Cars Initiative (1)
- Evaleau (1)
- Events (1)
- External effects (1)
- Fifa (1)
- Fmd (1)
- Food footprint (1)
- Food production (1)
- Ford (1)
- Forest ecosystems (1)
- Free trade (1)
- Freighter travel (1)
- GHG mitigation (1)
- Ghg reduction goals (1)
- Global compact (1)
- Global justice (1)
- Green business models (1)
- Green consumers (1)
- Green deal (1)
- Green new deal (1)
- Happy life years (1)
- Harze (1)
- Hdpe (1)
- Human development index (1)
- Human trafficking (1)
- ILCD Handbook (1)
- IPCC (1)
- ISO 14015 (1)
- ISO 14031 (1)
- ISO 14064 (1)
- ISO 14067 (1)
- ISO-14000 (1)
- ISO-14008 (1)
- ISO-14025 (1)
- ISO-14046 (1)
- Impact category (1)
- Incentive (1)
- Industry-4-0 (1)
- Information design (1)
- Input output (1)
- Input output economics (1)
- Intellectual property (1)
- Iso 14001 (1)
- Klimawandel (1)
- Kuznets curve (1)
- LIFE AskREACH (1)
- Lieferkettengesetz (1)
- Life cycle analysis (1)
- Life cycle perspective (1)
- Linkedin (1)
- Living planet report (1)
- Long-Term Pay (1)
- Material consumption (1)
- Material flow modeling (1)
- Material flowcosts (1)
- Material footprint (1)
- Mexico (1)
- Monetize external costs (1)
- Montreal Protocol (1)
- Natural Cost Accounting (1)
- Nature conservation (1)
- Nitrate pollution (1)
- Nutrients cycle (1)
- Okobilanzdatenbanken (1)
- Okolabelling (1)
- Okologischer fusabdruck (1)
- Online Resource Efficiency Platform OREP (1)
- Operational efficiency (1)
- Pas (1)
- Pcf (1)
- Philippines (1)
- Pilot program (1)
- Plastic industry (1)
- Pollution haven hypothesis (1)
- Process improvement (1)
- Process system engineering (1)
- Product management (1)
- Product stewardship (1)
- Product sustainability (1)
- Production planning (1)
- Produktlebensdauer (1)
- Prop 65 (1)
- Protection proprietary data (1)
- Pvc (1)
- Qatar (1)
- Quality journalism (1)
- Rapid prototyping (1)
- Refuse derived fuel plant (1)
- Renewable methane (1)
- Renewable process heat (1)
- Retailer (1)
- Rio20 summit (1)
- Rolf Dobelli (1)
- Social ecological resilience (1)
- Solar thermal energy (1)
- Sorgfaltspflichtengesetz (1)
- South africa (1)
- Supermarket chain (1)
- Sustainability performance (1)
- Sustainability strategy (1)
- Sustainable architecture (1)
- Sustainable living (1)
- Sustainable resins (1)
- Sydney (1)
- System analysis (1)
- Telecommunications (1)
- Total material consumption (1)
- Treibhauspotenzial (1)
- Turkey (1)
- UK CA (1)
- University (1)
- VDMA (1)
- Vertical cooperation (1)
- Waste prevention (1)
- Wind power (1)
- World cup (1)
- World vegan day (1)
- Yet (1)
- Zero carbon city (1)
- academia (1)
- acidification (1)
- air quality (1)
- aluminum (1)
- amazon (1)
- antarctic ozone hole (1)
- apocalypse (1)
- apple (1)
- assessment (1)
- atmospheric carbon measurement (1)
- background database (1)
- battery change station (1)
- bike sharing (1)
- bio capacity (1)
- bio-economy (1)
- biocapacity (1)
- biological gas treatment (1)
- blogs (1)
- books (1)
- business opportunity (1)
- car (1)
- carbon emissions (1)
- carbon free city (1)
- carbon leakage (1)
- carbon management (1)
- carbon management 2 (1)
- carbon reduction (1)
- carbon tax (1)
- carbon-neutral travel (1)
- cargo shipping (1)
- carton (1)
- certification (1)
- change (1)
- climate impact (1)
- climate neutral (1)
- co2 fusabdruck (1)
- cogeneration (1)
- combined reporting (1)
- commons (1)
- cooperation along product (1)
- cradle to cradle (1)
- de-growth economy (1)
- digital battery passport (1)
- ecarus (1)
- eco design (1)
- ecoinvent (1)
- ecological tax reform (1)
- ecosystem disturbance (1)
- efficiency investment (1)
- efficient construction (1)
- energy efficiency in production (1)
- energy sources (1)
- environmental accounting (1)
- environmental impact data (1)
- environmental management system (1)
- environmental performance indicator (1)
- environmental technology verification (1)
- environmentally friendly raw materials (1)
- esg (1)
- fashion (1)
- food loss (1)
- food sector (1)
- gate-to-gate approach (1)
- geopolymer cement (1)
- green Christmas (1)
- green buildings (1)
- green paradox (1)
- green production (1)
- greenhouse (1)
- handprinting (1)
- holistic sustainability (1)
- lca-software (1)
- lcia (1)
- lifecycle (1)
- logitech (1)
- management models (1)
- material flow balance (1)
- material losses (1)
- material-flow-accounts (1)
- media (1)
- modeling (1)
- nuclear phase out (1)
- policy instruments (1)
- politics (1)
- post oil age (1)
- product environmental footprint (1)
- production circle (1)
- ressource efficiency analysis (1)
- saving potentials (1)
- scope 3 (1)
- season's greetings (1)
- smart meter (1)
- social cost accounting (1)
- stranded assets (1)
- sustainability control (1)
- sustainability projects (1)
- sustainable products (1)
- tajikistan (1)
- textile industry (1)
- textile refinement (1)
- toyota (1)
- trade (1)
- transport emissions (1)
- uk-rohs (1)
- umweltbilanz (1)
- urban carbon emissions (1)
- velib (1)
- volvo (1)
- waste air treatment (1)
- waste hierarchy (1)
- wastewater (1)
- water stress (1)
- wind gas (1)
- world statistics day (1)
- zero growth (1)
- Ökologischer Fußabdruck (1)