There are these technical terms – complicated words with Latin origins – that experts have used for ages without any outsider noticing. All of a sudden one of these terms magically manages to escape the academic ivory tower. Enjoying newly found freedom, the term slowly makes its way into the mainstream. But the road is long and hard, the poor term runs the risk of being misused. Resilience is one of these terms, a tricky little word with many meanings and different connotations. Resilience is now on the verge of making it to the masses. Well, maybe not the masses, but to a broader community of sustainability oriented clientele. Light will be shed on three uses of the term resilience today, paving the way for correct usage and a happy life for resilience ever after.
1.Resilience (Physics)
This is the easy part. As Wikipedia says, “Resilience is the ability of a material to absorb energy when it is deformed elastically, and release that energy upon unloading.” You squeeze a sponge, and upon unloading, it expands to its original form.
2. Resilience (Ecology)
Crawford Stanley Holling, the godfather of ecosystem resilience, introduced the concept as early as 1973. Basically, it expands the physical definition to apply it to ecosystems. So ecosystem resilience refers to the ability of a system to absorb a disturbance without losing its stability. Think a forest recovering from a fire. Trees turn to ashes, but eventually, new trees start growing and after a long enough time span, the forest turns green and prosperous again. But, of course, disturbances are not only of natural origin, like a forest fire can be. Holling identified four different ways in which ecosystems change dynamically. Charles Perrings summarized them in one of his “Selected Essays” (1997, 48):
Holling (1973, 1986, 1992) has described the dynamics of ecosystems in terms of the sequential interaction between four system functions. These are exploitation – processes responsible for rapid colonization of disturbed ecosystems; conservation – the accumulation of energy and biomass; creative destruction – abrupt change caused by external disturbance which releases energy and matter; and reorganization – mobilization of matter for the next exploitative phase.
Unfortunately, it is not as easy as this. There is a second approach to ecological resilience. Peter Schulze called it the engineering resilience of ecological resilience, as opposed to the ecological resilience. He reviews these two approaches as follows (1996, 47):
One definition focuses on efficiency, constancy, and predictability – all attributes at the core of engineers’ desires for fail-safe design. The other focuses on persistence, change, and unpredictability – all attributes embraced and celebrated by biologists with an evolutionary perspective and by those who search for safe-fail designs.
Concerning the latter definition of ecological resilience, interesting conclusions can be drawn. Perrings, for instance, said that nature can never be priced. What we would expect from resilience, monetizing ecological limits, is in fact impossible (Perrings 1997, 60):
[At] the root of the problem is a rather less-worn fact that many of the key ecological processes are neither observable nor controllable, and that the basic boundaries are not well defined. No allocation of property rights, no reform of government pricing policies, no estimate of the willingness to pay for public goods can change this.
Instead of showing the exact limits of pollution, the concept of resilience can only show possible risks. It is, he continued, rather a means of risk management:
In these circumstances, the best that can be achieved through environmental management is the stabilization of the system at sustainable levels of activity, and this is the same as the protection of system resilience (Perrings, 1991). Nor is it possible to evaluate the costs and benefits of stabilization. Since the location of the unstable manifolds that constitute the thresholds of resilience and the system dynamics beyond those thresholds are generally not known, there is a very large element of fundamental uncertainty about the cost of approaching the thresholds of resilience.
[…]A strategy for sustainable development within a finite system is essentially a strategy for containing and insuring against [the potential for unanticipated and ‘catastrophic’ effects] risks.
3. Social-Ecological Resilience
The social or social-ecological resilience is the one Inci Goekmen talked about in a knowtheflow-interview from March. It is the most integrative approach to resilience, the one that also makes the most sense from my point of view. Berkes, Colding and Folke (2003) gave the reasons why. Nothing beats a comprehensive definition – I allow myself to leave the stage now and let Berkes et al. draw the conclusion:
Not only are there natural disturbances, such as forest fires and insect outbreaks, but many human activities, such as resource use and pollution, which also create disturbances. Ecosystem responses to resource use, and the reciprocal response of people to changes in ecosystems, constitute coupled, dynamic systems that exhibit adaptive behaviour (Gunderson et al., 1995). This recognition brings into focus the second and third defining characteristics of resilience, those regarding self-organization and learning. It underscores the importance of considering linked social-ecological systems, rather than ecosystems or social systems in isolation (Berkes and Folke, 1998).
If you wish to explore practical research results in the frame of social-ecological resilience, I suggest a dive right into the publications of the Stockholm Resilience Centre.
Further Reading
- Berkes, F., Colding, J., Folke, C. (2003), Navigating Social-Ecological Systems: Building Resilience for Complexity and Change, Cambridge University Press. Google Books Link
- Gunderson, L. H., Allen, C. R., & Holling, C. S. (2009). Foundations of ecological resilience. Washington, DC: Island Press.
- Perrings, C. (1997), Economics of Ecological Resources: Selected Essays, Edward Elgar Publishing.
- Schulze, P.C. (1996), Engineering Within Ecological Constraints, National Academies Press. Google Books link
Article image by Drew Coffman
- Products & Solutions (99)
- Trends & Technology (99)
- News & Updates (68)
- Challenges (67)
- Sustainability (48)
- life cycle assessment (44)
- Compliance (29)
- Energy efficiency (29)
- carbon footprint (23)
- circular economy (23)
- echa (21)
- Resource efficiency (19)
- SCIP (19)
- LCA (18)
- material efficiency (18)
- Umberto (17)
- Climate Change (16)
- Material flow cost accounting (15)
- material flow analysis (12)
- Renewable energy (11)
- Process Optimization (10)
- environmental product declaration (9)
- Ecodesign (8)
- Efficiency (8)
- Transparency (8)
- Trends (8)
- life cycle inventory (8)
- Customer driven-sustainability (7)
- Eco label (7)
- Ecological footprint (7)
- Ipoint suite (7)
- Lca databases (7)
- Supply chain (7)
- Survey (7)
- Sustainable development (7)
- automotive (7)
- blockchain (7)
- Reach (6)
- Renewable heat (6)
- research (6)
- China (5)
- Corporate carbon footprint (5)
- Digitalization (5)
- Industrial ecology (5)
- Materialflusskostenrechnung (5)
- carbon footprinting (5)
- carbon neutrality (5)
- digital product passport (5)
- waste management (5)
- Climate protection (4)
- Cobalt reporting (4)
- Dematerialization (4)
- EPD (4)
- GHG reduction (4)
- Green construction (4)
- OECD (4)
- Okobilanzierung (4)
- Social metabolism (4)
- Sustainable transport (4)
- carbon neutral (4)
- construction industry (4)
- germany (4)
- Big Data (3)
- Brexit (3)
- Chemical industry (3)
- Conflict minerals (3)
- Corporate Social Responsibility (3)
- Database (3)
- Due diligence (3)
- E-mobility (3)
- Environmental product declarations (3)
- Eutrophication (3)
- IFEU (3)
- ISO 50001 (3)
- Industrial sector (3)
- Innovation (3)
- Leed (3)
- Life cycle management (3)
- Medical device (3)
- Photovoltaics (3)
- Ressourceneffizienz (3)
- Social media (3)
- building sector (3)
- greenhouse gas inventory (3)
- svhc (3)
- transport sector (3)
- water footprint (3)
- 20-20-20 Objectives (2)
- 3D printing (2)
- BASF (2)
- Christian-Doppler-Laboratory (2)
- Competence center (2)
- Conflict minerals reporting (2)
- Cycling (2)
- E-car (2)
- Electric car (2)
- Emerging economies (2)
- Environmental impact (2)
- Environmental management (2)
- Environmental performance (2)
- Environmental sustainability index (2)
- European commission (2)
- Fish (2)
- Gate to gate (2)
- Global warming (2)
- Governance (2)
- Green business 2 (2)
- Green investment (2)
- Human rights (2)
- ISO-14051 (2)
- Inatba (2)
- Integrated reporting (2)
- Integrative approach (2)
- Knowledge economy (2)
- LCA data from suppliers (2)
- Life cycle thinking (2)
- MFA (2)
- Manufacturing industry (2)
- Okobilanz (2)
- Renewable Resources (2)
- Sdgs (2)
- Software (2)
- Steady state economy (2)
- Sustainable business (2)
- Sustainable lifestyle (2)
- UK REACH (2)
- Umberto for carbon footprint (2)
- Umweltbundesamt (2)
- Wastewater treatment (2)
- Water management (2)
- agriculture (2)
- best practice (2)
- biodiversity (2)
- biomass (2)
- building standards (2)
- carbon emissions (2)
- carbon intensity (2)
- carbon relocation (2)
- collaborative consumption (2)
- consistency (2)
- corporate material flow modeling (2)
- cost savings (2)
- developing world (2)
- eLCAr (2)
- energiewende (2)
- energy (2)
- esankey (2)
- food industry (2)
- green jobs (2)
- holistic approach (2)
- milk (2)
- modern slavery (2)
- okobilanzdaten (2)
- productivity (2)
- resilience (2)
- sankey diagram (2)
- seafood (2)
- transport (2)
- 2012 (1)
- 3 scopes (1)
- ACHEMA (1)
- AI (1)
- Abfallwirtschaft (1)
- Ankara (1)
- B2B (1)
- BMBF (1)
- BREEAM (1)
- Bachelor program (1)
- Bauwesen (1)
- Brazil (1)
- CFC (1)
- CO2-Fußabdruck (1)
- Carbon Accounting (1)
- Central america (1)
- Circular Economy Action Plan (1)
- Club of Rome (1)
- Co2 Pricing (1)
- Commercial Sector (1)
- Comparative life cycle assessment (1)
- Compliance agent (1)
- Composite indicator (1)
- Construction (1)
- Consumer goods (1)
- Consumption (1)
- Country Attractiveness (1)
- Creative sustainability (1)
- Critique of the green economy (1)
- Csr report (1)
- Dairy (1)
- Dashboard of sustainability (1)
- Data (1)
- Data collection (1)
- Davos (1)
- Decarbonization (1)
- Denmark (1)
- Design (1)
- Deutschland (1)
- Developing countries (1)
- Dienstleistungen (1)
- Digital twin (1)
- Distributed manufacturing (1)
- Divestment (1)
- Domestic fuel consumption (1)
- Domestic sector (1)
- Duty of care (1)
- Earth Sciences (1)
- Earth summit (1)
- Ecolabelling (1)
- Ecologic footprint (1)
- Ecological resilience (1)
- Education (1)
- Efficiency measures (1)
- Effizienzfabrik (1)
- Ehs (1)
- Emission relocation (1)
- Ems (1)
- Energieeffizienz (1)
- Energy Intensity by Sector (1)
- Energy contracting (1)
- Energy efficiency directive (1)
- Energy transition (1)
- Engineering excellence (1)
- Enhipro (1)
- Environment (1)
- Environmental Contracting (1)
- Environmental Engineering (1)
- Environmental balance (1)
- Environmental capital (1)
- Environmental labeling (1)
- Environmental management accounting (1)
- Environmental profit and loss statement (1)
- Environmental standard (1)
- Environmentally Weighed Material Consumption (1)
- European Comission (1)
- European Green Cars Initiative (1)
- Evaleau (1)
- Events (1)
- External effects (1)
- Fifa (1)
- Fishery (1)
- Fmd (1)
- Food footprint (1)
- Food production (1)
- Ford (1)
- Forest ecosystems (1)
- France (1)
- Free trade (1)
- Freighter travel (1)
- Full cost accounting (1)
- GHG mitigation (1)
- Ghg reduction goals (1)
- Global compact (1)
- Global justice (1)
- Global warming potential (1)
- Green building (1)
- Green business models (1)
- Green consumers (1)
- Green deal (1)
- Green new deal (1)
- Greenwash (1)
- HVAC (1)
- Happy life years (1)
- Harmonization (1)
- Harze (1)
- Hdpe (1)
- Human development index (1)
- Human trafficking (1)
- ILCD Handbook (1)
- IPCA (1)
- IPCC (1)
- ISO 14015 (1)
- ISO 14031 (1)
- ISO 14064 (1)
- ISO 14067 (1)
- ISO-14000 (1)
- ISO-14008 (1)
- ISO-14025 (1)
- ISO-14046 (1)
- Impact category (1)
- Incentive (1)
- Incentive based pay (1)
- Incineration (1)
- India (1)
- Industry-4-0 (1)
- Information design (1)
- Input output (1)
- Input output databases (1)
- Input output economics (1)
- Inreff (1)
- Intellectual property (1)
- Internalization of externalities (1)
- International standards (1)
- Interplant collaboration (1)
- Iso 14001 (1)
- Jevons paradox (1)
- Klimawandel (1)
- Konsumguter (1)
- Kuznets curve (1)
- LIFE AskREACH (1)
- Lieferkettengesetz (1)
- Life cycle analysis (1)
- Life cycle perspective (1)
- Life style (1)
- Linkedin (1)
- Living planet report (1)
- Long-Term Pay (1)
- Material consumption (1)
- Material flow modeling (1)
- Material flowcosts (1)
- Material footprint (1)
- Medical device regulation (1)
- Metal industry (1)
- Mexico (1)
- Monetize external costs (1)
- Montreal Protocol (1)
- Municipal solid waste (1)
- Natural Cost Accounting (1)
- Nature conservation (1)
- Nitrate pollution (1)
- Nutrients balance (1)
- Nutrients cycle (1)
- OECD Environment Policy Committee (1)
- Okobilanzdatenbanken (1)
- Okolabelling (1)
- Okologischer fusabdruck (1)
- Online Resource Efficiency Platform OREP (1)
- Operational efficiency (1)
- Outsourcing (1)
- PET (1)
- Pas (1)
- Pcf (1)
- Philippines (1)
- Pilot program (1)
- Plastic industry (1)
- Polio (1)
- Pollution haven hypothesis (1)
- Process engineering (1)
- Process improvement (1)
- Process system engineering (1)
- Product management (1)
- Product stewardship (1)
- Product sustainability (1)
- Production based CO2 Productivity (1)
- Production planning (1)
- Produktlebensdauer (1)
- Prop 65 (1)
- Protection proprietary data (1)
- Qatar (1)
- Quality (1)
- Quality journalism (1)
- Rapid prototyping (1)
- Refuse derived fuel plant (1)
- Renewable energy in manufacturing (1)
- Renewable methane (1)
- Renewable process heat (1)
- Renewable raw material (1)
- Resource flows (1)
- Retailer (1)
- Rio20 summit (1)
- Rolf Dobelli (1)
- Sap (1)
- Sfdr (1)
- Shopping rage (1)
- Smart grid (1)
- Social ecological resilience (1)
- Solar thermal energy (1)
- Sorgfaltspflichtengesetz (1)
- South africa (1)
- Soy milk (1)
- Stakeholder management (1)
- Supermarket chain (1)
- Sustainability indicators (1)
- Sustainability performance (1)
- Sustainability strategy (1)
- Sustainable architecture (1)
- Sustainable construction (1)
- Sustainable living (1)
- Sustainable process index (1)
- Sustainable resins (1)
- Sustainable resource management (1)
- Sydney (1)
- System analysis (1)
- Telecommunications (1)
- Tobias viere (1)
- Total material consumption (1)
- Treibhauspotenzial (1)
- Turkey (1)
- UK CA (1)
- University (1)
- Upcycling (1)
- VDMA (1)
- Vertical cooperation (1)
- Waste prevention (1)
- Water abstraction rate (1)
- Water extraction (1)
- Wind power (1)
- World cup (1)
- World vegan day (1)
- Yet (1)
- Zero carbon city (1)
- Zero emission mobility (1)
- academia (1)
- acidification (1)
- air quality (1)
- aluminum (1)
- amazon (1)
- antarctic ozone hole (1)
- apocalypse (1)
- apple (1)
- assessment (1)
- atmospheric carbon measurement (1)
- background database (1)
- battery change station (1)
- bike sharing (1)
- bio capacity (1)
- bio-economy (1)
- biocapacity (1)
- biological gas treatment (1)
- blogs (1)
- books (1)
- business opportunity (1)
- car (1)
- carbon free city (1)
- carbon leakage (1)
- carbon management (1)
- carbon management 2 (1)
- carbon reduction (1)
- carbon tax (1)
- carbon-neutral travel (1)
- cargo shipping (1)
- carton (1)
- certification (1)
- change (1)
- climate impact (1)
- climate neutral (1)
- co2 fusabdruck (1)
- cogeneration (1)
- combined reporting (1)
- commons (1)
- cooperation along product (1)
- cradle to cradle (1)
- de-growth economy (1)
- digital battery passport (1)
- ecarus (1)
- eco design (1)
- ecoinvent (1)
- ecological tax reform (1)
- ecosystem disturbance (1)
- efficiency investment (1)
- efficient construction (1)
- energy efficiency in production (1)
- energy sources (1)
- environmental accounting (1)
- environmental impact data (1)
- environmental management system (1)
- environmental performance indicator (1)
- environmental technology verification (1)
- environmentally friendly raw materials (1)
- esg (1)
- fashion (1)
- food loss (1)
- food sector (1)
- geopolymer cement (1)
- green Christmas (1)
- green buildings (1)
- green paradox (1)
- green production (1)
- greenhouse (1)
- handprinting (1)
- holistic sustainability (1)
- lca recommendations (1)
- lca-software (1)
- lcia (1)
- lifecycle (1)
- logitech (1)
- management models (1)
- material flow balance (1)
- material losses (1)
- material-flow-accounts (1)
- media (1)
- modeling (1)
- nuclear phase out (1)
- policy instruments (1)
- politics (1)
- post oil age (1)
- product environmental footprint (1)
- production circle (1)
- ressource efficiency analysis (1)
- saving potentials (1)
- scope 3 (1)
- season's greetings (1)
- smart meter (1)
- social cost accounting (1)
- stranded assets (1)
- sustainability control (1)
- sustainability projects (1)
- sustainable products (1)
- tajikistan (1)
- textile industry (1)
- textile refinement (1)
- toyota (1)
- trade (1)
- transport emissions (1)
- uk-rohs (1)
- umweltbilanz (1)
- urban carbon emissions (1)
- velib (1)
- volvo (1)
- waste air treatment (1)
- waste hierarchy (1)
- wastewater (1)
- water stress (1)
- wind gas (1)
- world statistics day (1)
- zero growth (1)
- Ökologischer Fußabdruck (1)